| Platinum | Cosi Cucina Italian Grill |
| Gold | OPA! Italian & Greek |
| Silver | Christophers |
| Bronze | Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano |
| Top Pick | A Taste of Italy |
| Top Pick | Billy Vee’s Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Centro Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Gusto Pizza |
| Top Pick | Noah's Ark Restaurant & Lounge |